Q Qudoy

CNY ¥
English

Community English translation · version 44f57b0. Translation dates and coverage may differ from the Chinese edition. China-specific policy guidance retains its original jurisdiction.

← Back to guideChildren after starting school

When disciplining, do not hit, and do not yell or call them stupid: children often hit or yelled at have more behavior and mood problems

Source evidence grade ARead applicability below

In plain terms

Children often hit are more aggressive and have more mental problems, are more distant from parents, and get heavier hitting more often. Whether hitting makes a child obey on the spot is unclear in the evidence. Children often yelled at or called stupid at age 13 later get in more trouble and have more depression; even warm parenting day to day does not cancel that.

Cost

No money. The hard part is stopping hands and mouth when anger rises, and switching to a way of parenting without hitting or yelling. What to switch to is in item 17 of this section (parenting classes that teach concrete skills).

Benefit

First, hitting. One meta-analysis counted only “open-hand spanking of the buttocks or limbs.” It pooled 75 studies, 111 effect sizes, 160927 children. Of 17 outcomes, 13 clearly linked to spanking, all in the bad direction. d is effect size; 0.2 is small, 0.5 medium. Childhood aggression d = 0.37 (95% CI 0.13–0.61, credible range). Externalizing problems 0.41 — hitting, breaking rules. Internalizing 0.24 — anxiety, depression. Mental health problems 0.53; poor relationship with parents 0.51; low self-esteem 0.15; poorer cognition 0.17. Physical abuse by parents 0.64. Adult antisocial behavior 0.36; adult mental health problems 0.24. Across 111 effect sizes, d = 0.33 (0.29–0.38). Whether the child obeyed on the spot was not clearly linked to spanking (d = 0.14, −0.19–0.47); that outcome had only 5 effect sizes. Another review looked only at before-and-after follow-up studies, 69 of them. Physical punishment stably predicted more later behavior problems; no link to any long-term good outcome was seen. Of 7 studies that counted how often hitting happened, 5 found more hitting linked to worse problems. Next, yelling. A U.S. study followed 976 two-parent families. At age 13, if parents often yelled, used foul language, or called the child stupid or lazy, misconduct and depressive symptoms both rose between ages 13 and 14. Whether parents were usually warm did not cancel the link. The reverse also held: children with more misconduct at 13 later got yelled at more. In law, parents must not use domestic violence against a child. Article 2 of the Anti-Domestic Violence Law (反家庭暴力法) lists forms of domestic violence: beating, binding, maiming, restricting personal liberty, and habitual insults and intimidation. Article 12 requires guardians to do family education in civilized ways. When parents infringe a child’s rights, residents’ and villagers’ committees must counsel and stop them, and report serious cases to public security. Public security, procuratorates, and courts that find this must admonish the parents and may order them to accept family-education guidance (nationwide)

Applicability and notes

Controversial. Almost all these studies only follow records and have no assigned controls, so they cannot show which caused which. In the spanking meta-analysis, 72% of studies only looked at whether two things appeared together, or relied on later recall. Another meta-analysis took only before-and-after follow-up studies. After subtracting the child’s prior behavior, the link of spanking to externalizing problems fell to 0.07, and to internalizing to 0.10. Those authors judged the effect small. Still another meta-analysis found “conditional spanking” better than 10 of 13 other discipline methods at reducing defiance and antisocial behavior. It also found that hitting too hard or relying mainly on hitting was worse than other methods. So the opposing side can show: light, conditional spanking is not necessarily worse than other methods. Heavy hitting and frequent hitting and yelling are worse on both sides. An occasional single hit or shout is not named domestic violence in the statute, which names beating and habitual insults and intimidation. Main beneficiaries are children. If someone else in the household hits the child, police reports and protection orders are in Section 8, item 43 (personal safety protection order). Anyone who sees long-term hitting of a child in another household may dissuade or report to public security, civil affairs, or education. For a stranger’s household, calling 110 or telling the residents’ committee is enough — do not go in yourself to break up a fight.

Original sources

Gershoff ET, Grogan-Kaylor A. (2016). Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453–469. https://doi.org/10.1037/fam0000191;Heilmann A, Mehay A, Watt RG, et al. (2021). Physical punishment and child outcomes: a narrative review of prospective studies. Lancet, 398(10297), 355–364. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(21)00582-1;Wang MT, Kenny S. (2014). Longitudinal links between fathers' and mothers' harsh verbal discipline and adolescents' conduct problems and depressive symptoms. Child Development, 85(3), 908–923. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.12143;Ferguson CJ. (2013). Spanking, corporal punishment and negative long-term outcomes: a meta-analytic review of longitudinal studies. Clinical Psychology Review, 33(1), 196–208. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2012.11.002;Larzelere RE, Kuhn BR. (2005). Comparing child outcomes of physical punishment and alternative disciplinary tactics: a meta-analysis. Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review, 8(1), 1–37. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10567-005-2340-z;全国人大常委会 (2015). 反家庭暴力法(第二、十二条). https://flk.npc.gov.cn/detail?id=2c909fdd678bf17901678bf7f9d60889;全国人大常委会 (2024 年修正). 未成年人保护法(第十一、十七、一百一十八条). https://flk.npc.gov.cn/detail?id=ff8081818f197cf001905e567af635a0;全国人大常委会 (2021). 家庭教育促进法(第二十三、五十三条). https://flk.npc.gov.cn/detail?id=ff8081817cac3b2d017cac5a6c6f0109

Sign in to save →

Original location:30.16 · View source file

Content sources

eternity4719 · 高性价比人生指南 · CC BY 4.0 · Interface and reading experience adapted by Qudoy · dlgrv · English translation

What would you like to do?

Choose an available tool to get started.

Media link parserOne link. Videos, photos and music, neatly unpacked.Membership dealsCompare equivalent membership offers and recorded price history.AI subscription pricesCompare ChatGPT, Claude and Grok regional plans, local prices and supplied CNY equivalents.Gold prices todayCompare bank bullion, jewellery and recycling prices, calculate reference amounts and track recorded quotes.AI reset monitorMonitor public quota-related clues and subscribe to email or browser alerts.Fuel pricesCompare fuel prices in China and selected markets.Tech dealsBrowse tech product specifications, offer conditions and channel prices.Study funding finderFind study funding by destination, degree and support, compare conditions and visit official sources.Life guideExplore everyday guidance, costs, evidence and original sources.Workplace & WeChat communicationRead workplace scenarios, WeChat etiquette and example wording, with original sources.IP Geolocation LookupQuery online providers for the registered region, network operator and ASN of an IPv4 or IPv6 address. Locations are approximate.Domain safety checkCheck DNS records, reachability, redirects and the HTTPS certificate of a domain.DNS record lookupQuery A, AAAA, CNAME, MX, NS, TXT and SOA records over DoH using Alibaba or DNSPOD resolvers.Whois lookupRead raw registry WHOIS data over TCP 43 for common domain extensions and IP addresses.IndexNow submissionSubmit batches of URLs to IndexNow-enabled search engines so new pages get discovered faster.AI image studioCreate images from prompts and references.