Don’t give up calcium to prevent kidney stones
In plain terms
People who have had calcium-oxalate stones are often told to eat less calcium; trial results go the other way. Men with recurrent stones who ate normal calcium while cutting animal protein and salt had, over five years, half the recurrence of those on a low-calcium diet. UK guidelines also say not to restrict calcium.
Cost
No money. It even saves effort: you need not watch every day which foods contain calcium.
Benefit
A 5-year randomized controlled trial enrolled 120 men with recurrent calcium-oxalate stones and high urine calcium (idiopathic hypercalciuria). They were randomized into two groups. One ate normal calcium, 30 mmol a day, while also cutting animal protein (52 g a day) and salt (50 mmol sodium chloride a day). The other ate a traditional low-calcium diet, 10 mmol a day. Over 5 years recurrences were 12/60 versus 23/60. Unadjusted relative risk 0.49 (95% CI 0.24–0.98, the credible range), P=0.04 — recurrence risk on normal calcium was half. During follow-up, urine calcium fell about 170 mg a day in both groups. But urine oxalate differed. The low-calcium group rose a mean 5.4 mg a day; the normal-calcium group fell a mean 7.2 mg a day. UK NICE guideline NG118 item 1.8.1 states not to restrict daily calcium intake. Adults keep 700 to 1200 mg a day. Children and teens 350 to 1000 mg a day by age. Giving up calcium looks worthwhile because of the intuition “stones are made of calcium, so eat less calcium.”
Applicability and notes
Controversy: The trial was only in men, all with recurrent calcium-oxalate stones and high urine calcium; it does not transfer directly to every stone type. Also the trial arm changed three things at once — normal calcium, less animal protein, less salt — so you cannot credit all benefit to “not giving up calcium.” Low salt and less animal protein may also be working. What to reject is “actively cutting calcium-containing foods,” not “you should take more calcium.” What changed here is calcium in daily meals; calcium supplements are separate — whether someone with past stones should take supplements is a question for the treating doctor. Drinking more water: Section 16, Item 8 (after kidney stones, drink 2.5–3 litres a day).
Original sources
Borghi L, Schianchi T, Meschi T, et al. (2002). Comparison of two diets for the prevention of recurrent stones in idiopathic hypercalciuria. New England Journal of Medicine, 346(2), 77-84. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa010369;National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2019). Renal and ureteric stones: assessment and management. NICE guideline NG118,第 1.8.1 条. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng118/chapter/Recommendations
Original location:6.21 · View source file