Q Qudoy

CNY ¥
English

Community English translation · version 44f57b0. Translation dates and coverage may differ from the Chinese edition. China-specific policy guidance retains its original jurisdiction.

← Back to guideAfter a major blow

Do not start by paying for grief counseling; first see whether your grief is really stuck (the signs in item 8)

Source evidence grade ARead applicability below

In plain terms

Arranging psychological counseling for every bereaved person brings a small benefit, and after a while it can no longer be seen, because most people would have eased on their own. For people who already clearly cannot adapt, treatment works as well as treatment for other psychological problems. So check item 8 first (grief that is stuck, go to psychiatry). Spend this money only if it matches.

Cost

No money. The other way around, you save a counseling fee.

Benefit

61 controlled studies taken together. Giving psychological intervention to bereaved people in general shows a very small benefit just when treatment ends, and looking again after an interval shows no benefit left. Interventions that enroll only bereaved people who "already clearly cannot adapt" work as well as psychological treatment for other psychological problems. Studies that do no screening beforehand come out poorly, because the group that got no intervention would also have eased on its own over time. Another 14 trials that assigned people by lot, taken together: treatment for people who already had a problem was clearly better than the control both after treatment and at later visits, and after an interval the effect was still growing. Preventive intervention given in general to people who did not yet have a problem did not work. Another study followed 205 people from before the spouse died through 6 and 18 months after. That study separated 5 paths. They were ordinary grief, prolonged grief, prolonged depression, getting better during the bereavement, and resilience (able to hold up). Resilience was the most common. Ordinary grief was relatively uncommon.

Applicability and notes

What this says is "not everyone has to do it," not "nobody should do it." The high-risk bereavement in item 4 (a relative died by suicide, accident, or homicide) is exactly the kind the evidence supports doing. So is the kind in item 8 (grief that is stuck, go to psychiatry), the people who are already stuck. A Lancet review reaches the same conclusion: grief is not an illness, and most people do not need a professional intervention. The effort should go to people at high risk. It should also go to people who have already developed complicated grief, depression after the bereavement, and a stress disorder.

Original sources

Currier JM, et al. (2008). The effectiveness of psychotherapeutic interventions for bereaved persons: a comprehensive quantitative review. Psychological Bulletin. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.134.5.648;Wittouck C, et al. (2011). The prevention and treatment of complicated grief: a meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2010.09.005;Bonanno GA, et al. (2002). Resilience to loss and chronic grief: a prospective study from preloss to 18-months postloss. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.83.5.1150;Stroebe M 等 (2007). Health outcomes of bereavement. Lancet. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(07)61816-9(备注里那份综述)

Sign in to save →

Original location:29.9 · View source file

Content sources

eternity4719 · 高性价比人生指南 · CC BY 4.0 · Interface and reading experience adapted by Qudoy · dlgrv · English translation

What would you like to do?

Choose an available tool to get started.

Media link parserOne link. Videos, photos and music, neatly unpacked.Membership dealsCompare equivalent membership offers and recorded price history.AI subscription pricesCompare ChatGPT, Claude and Grok regional plans, local prices and supplied CNY equivalents.Gold prices todayCompare bank bullion, jewellery and recycling prices, calculate reference amounts and track recorded quotes.AI reset monitorMonitor public quota-related clues and subscribe to email or browser alerts.Fuel pricesCompare fuel prices in China and selected markets.Tech dealsBrowse tech product specifications, offer conditions and channel prices.Study funding finderFind study funding by destination, degree and support, compare conditions and visit official sources.Life guideExplore everyday guidance, costs, evidence and original sources.Workplace & WeChat communicationRead workplace scenarios, WeChat etiquette and example wording, with original sources.IP Geolocation LookupQuery online providers for the registered region, network operator and ASN of an IPv4 or IPv6 address. Locations are approximate.Domain safety checkCheck DNS records, reachability, redirects and the HTTPS certificate of a domain.DNS record lookupQuery A, AAAA, CNAME, MX, NS, TXT and SOA records over DoH using Alibaba or DNSPOD resolvers.Whois lookupRead raw registry WHOIS data over TCP 43 for common domain extensions and IP addresses.IndexNow submissionSubmit batches of URLs to IndexNow-enabled search engines so new pages get discovered faster.AI image studioCreate images from prompts and references.